We had no idea exactly what to expect going into the first-ever Boneyard Match, but now the entire WWE Universe is buzzing after witnessing The Undertaker’s win over AJ Styles at WrestleMania 36.

Superstars from past and present, and so many others, took to Twitter to share their thoughts.

Hall of Famer Mick Foley — who knows a thing or two about tussling with The Dead Man — appealed to The WWE Chairman himself for an opportunity to be involved in a similar spectacle in the future.

Michelle McCool, The Undertaker’s own wife and former Divas Champion — whose name Styles disrespectfully evoked numerous times in recent weeks — was happy to take a victory lap following her husband’s win.

Thx sis! Some fools gotta learn the hard way🤣#BoneyardMatch https://t.co/2VZSmHUw6u

— McCool (@McCoolMichelleL) April 5, 2020

Metallica celebrated The Undertaker’s arrival to their song “Now That We’re Dead.”

The legacy continues. @WWE superstar The @Undertaker walked out to “Now That We’re Dead” on @WWENetwork! pic.twitter.com/mC4hCGLpOm

— Metallica (@Metallica) April 5, 2020

New Day member Xavier Woods didn’t hide his feelings on the unique encounter.

OMG I LOVED IT

— Austin Creed (@AustinCreedWins) April 5, 2020

Sasha Banks, who vies for the SmackDown Women’s Championship tomorrow on Part 2 of WrestleMania 36, also voiced her praise.

I am clapping #BoneyardMatch #Wrestlemania36 pic.twitter.com/nfU1LV3ryN

— Mercedes Moné Varnado (@MercedesVarnado) April 5, 2020

Former NFL Pro Bowler Pat McAfee also joined in.

That Undertaker/AJ Styles Boneyard Match might’ve been my favorite thing I’ve ever watched #Wrestlemania36 pic.twitter.com/MGKWxsw7H9

— Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) April 5, 2020

Hall of Famer elect JBL, who joined Michael Cole on commentary earlier in the evening, called it the best “out of ring fight” he had ever witnessed.

At @wwe Wrestlemania 25-Shawn Michaels and Undertaker had the best match I’ve ever seen. Tonight. Undertaker puts on a spectacle with AJ Styles that was best ‘out of ring’ fight I’ve ever seen. The G.O.A.T.

— John Layfield (@JCLayfield) April 5, 2020

NXT Superstar Dominik Dijakovic didn’t hesitate to place the bout in the pantheon of all-time WrestleMania matches.

Though The Undertaker put Styles in the dirt, The Street Profits’ Montez Ford didn’t think that should keep him from holding up a red cup a la the Raw Tag Team Champions.

pic.twitter.com/mzj0hv0zmq

— 𝕂𝕚𝕟𝕘 𝕋𝕖𝕫 (@MontezFordWWE) April 5, 2020