Superstars who should've been bigger: photos | WWE

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

Why wasn’t the immensely talented Bam Bam Bigelow one of the top villains of the ’90s?

1 / 38

1 / 38

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

Few Superstars were as highly respected by their peers as the great Brad Armstrong.

1 / 38

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

Chris Candido was highly talented, but never made it as a main event star.

1 / 38

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

Shawn Michaels touted Hakushi as the “greatest Japanese wrestler," so why didn’t he ever live up to the hype?

1 / 38

1 / 38

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

With the coveted NWA World Championship in his sights, Magnum TA suffered a career-ending injury in 1986.

1 / 38

1 / 38

1 / 38

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

Debuting in September 2000, Mark Jindrak & Sean O’Haire seemed poised to become the future of sports-entertainment.

1 / 38

1 / 38

1 / 38

1 / 38

1 / 38

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

Advertisement: Click the arrow to continue

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

Instead of dominating WCW, gifted heavyweight Mike Awesome was billed as "That '70s Guy"

1 / 38

1 / 38

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

Instead of wielding CM Punk–like influence, Raven was often seen pushing a shopping cart in WWE’s Hardcore division.

1 / 38

1 / 38

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

Perry Saturn had all the tools to be a major player, but he never quite connected on a national scale.

1 / 38

1 / 38

1 / 38

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

The Sinister Minister is the greatest manager to never hit it big.

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

Terry Taylor was far more talented than his Red Rooster persona let on.

1 / 38

1 / 38

+ Show Caption

1 / 38

Tom Prichard was an underrated wrestler if there ever was one.

1 / 38

1 / 38